Fish On Fire Menu (2025 Update)

Welcome to Fish On Fire, a culinary gem nestled in Orlando, Florida, where vibrant flavors and a warm atmosphere converge. Here, guests can indulge in a menu brimming with coastal delights. Start your experience with Key West Shrimp Skewers, featuring succulent shrimp chargrilled to perfection and served over lemon butter rice, a true taste of Florida's coastal heritage.

The Cheese Fries and Chicken Finger Appetizers offer a comforting twist for those seeking familiar tastes. For mains, don’t miss the mouthwatering mahi tacos and shrimp and grits, praised for their rich flavors and expertly seasoned ingredients.

To wrap up your meal, delight in a slice of tangy Key Lime Pie or a Plant City Moon Pie. With live music and a welcoming vibe, Fish On Fire is dedicated to providing not just a meal, but an unforgettable dining experience.

Starters

Wekiwa Catfish Fingers

the wekiwa marina was one of our most favorite places to enjoy a fine florida meal of fried catfish and hushpuppies. eating corn meal dusted catfish fingers and watching the evening raccoon feedings on the opposite bank of the narrow river, is a memory those of us that have been around awhile remember fondly. our fresh catfish is locally sourced and wild caught. just to make you remember too.

US$7.50

Key West Shrimp Skewers

sweet, tender, large shrimp. char-grilled with our own blend of lemon, basil and thyme, resting on lemon butter rice. tasty morsels of the sea that remind you of why you're in florida.

US$7.00

Fried Shrimp Appetizer

the "fish" prepares for you, a half'a pound of sweet, large shrimp. lightly dusted with simple seasonings and fried to tender perfection. the recipe comes to us from the fine folks that host the grant, florida, volunteer seafood festival. it's held every february, just a day trip away, in the metropolis of grant, florida 32949. we serve these shrimp all year long. you can toss them with any of our sauces, but why would you want to.

US$9.00

Sesame Seared Ahi Tuna

we coat top of the line yellow fin tuna with black and white sesame seeds and sear it rare. served with sesame soy sauce and spiced wasabi. nobody does it better.

US$11.00

Allies Gator

alligator is better for your heart than the common chicken. less cholesterol and the "bite" of lobster. now, we take the gator and cut'm up in tender nuggets of white meat. the nuggets are then marinated in buttermilk, seasoned with everglades spices and fried to perfection. served up with fofer's remoulade. outstanding when tossed in one of our wing sauces.

US$9.00

Chicken Finger Appetizers

coastal cut boneless chicken is our way of taking the best part of the bird and slicing it up ourselves. we coat these succulent morsels with our everglades blend and gently fry them for you. you can get'em with the skin still on'm or without. of course we'll toss'm in a sauce for you.

US$6.00

Cheese Fries

a large order of fries topped with melted cheddar cheese with bacon bits, and a green onions sour cream sauce.

US$6.50

Soup

ask for today's selection.

Soup

Salads

Caesar Salad

classic hand tossed with parmesan cheese and homemade croutons. garnished with tomato wedges.

Greek Salad

mom's favorite. made the old world way with lots of feta cheese, red onions, tomato, pepperoncini, cucumbers, calamata olives and a blend of lemon juice, olive oil and mediterranean herbs.

Garden Salad

a run through the vegetable patch with iceberg lettuce, green leaf lettuce, tomato, cucumber, carrots, onion and bell peppers.

Chopped Salad

a new classic for old friends. discovered at our poker game, this hidden gem delivers pow to the taste buds and crunch to the brain. tons of root vegetables tossed with our homemade zesty vinaigrette dressing.

US$7.00

Mahi Mahi

a fish so good, it has 3 names. dorado, dolphin or mahi mahi; large flake, sweet and moist, bold seasonings increase flavor

US$16.00

Grouper

sourced from the gulf of mexico our grouper is light fleshed and and mild tasting. tins fish accepts all flavors well

US$18.00

Tuna Duo

our "secret special" for over 4 years. two 4 oz yellow fin tuna steaks, seared and encrusted with your choice of sesame seeds, cracked black pepper or blackening seasoning.

US$15.00

Catfish

our local, wild caught specially, coated in commeal breading, cracker filed

US$13.00

Sorrento Steak Tip

sirloin tips, cooked to temperature and dressed up with sauteed onions, mushrooms and melted provolone cheese

US$12.00

Sorrento Coastal Chicken

marinated in caribbean jerk seasoning topping with sauteed onions, mushrooms and melted provolone cheese.

US$12.00

Dinners

Burgers

Big John Burger

here's the beef good old fashioned american value here. our classic 1/2 pound hand formed all beef patty is char-grilled to your liking. served like a great american burger should be. well even throw some cheese on it for you. - salute!

US$9.00

Bacon Cheese Burger

our half pound burger with bacon and your choice of cheese.

US$10.00

Cajun Burger

a blackened burger with bacon, cajun gravy and provolone cheese

US$9.00

Mushroom Swiss

with sauteed mushroom and topped with swiss cheese

US$10.00

Bbb

a blackened burger with bleu cheese crumbles and bacon.

US$10.50

Cheese Grits

US$2.95

Garlic Bread

US$2.00

Cheese Fries

US$4.00

Cheese Bread

US$4.00

Accompaniments

Sides

French Fries

US$2.25

Red Potatoes

US$2.70

Rice

US$1.00

Collard Greens

US$2.25

Com On The Cob

US$1.90

Black Beans

US$2.70

Black Bean & Rice

US$2.70

Key Lime Pie

US$4.00

Banana Cream Pie

US$4.00

Plant City Moon Pie

US$5.00

Dessert